SNP's 'insane' Hate Crime Bill ripped apart by comedian as he warns powers may be 'abused'

0

The SNP’s latest Bill is “leaves open the possibility of the state abusing their power”, Andrew Doyle has warned. The comedian spoke to talkRADIO about the Scottish Government’s controversial new Hate Crime Bill. He criticised Scotland’s Justice Secretary Humza Yousaf over the proposal of imposing the legislation on theatres.

Mr Doyle told listeners: “There’s a provision in the bill about the performance of a play so even theatre is covered by this.

“He was questioned on this in Parliament and he acknowledged that it’d be probably quite unusual for the far right to be staging a play.

“But then he said let’s imagine they did and the far right, in other words, a group of Neo-Nazis or someone decided to put on a production of a play to stir up hatred.

“He said that they would then be prosecuted, the director could be prosecuted, the performers could be prosecuted.”

READ MORE: Sturgeon takes thinly veiled swipe at Boris as PM faces North revolt

He continued: “Does he really think that Neo-Nazis are attempting to recruit people through the medium of amateur dramatics? Does he think that’s likely?

“I don’t know any Neo-Nazis, but I know enough about them to know they’re not real fans of the theatre. I mean there’s too many gay people for one thing.

“I just think it’s insane and palpably nonsense, and that makes me think, ‘well if you’re coming up with these kind of scenarios, these outlandish, extraordinary, impossible scenarios to defend your bill, what is this bill really about?’

“The intentions were great. When it was originally proposed, it was meant to repeal these outdated blasphemy laws in Scotland.”

The legislation has sparked concerns that free speech could be curtailed as a result, prompting the Justice Secretary to announce measures to assuage these doubts.

He has already said that the Scottish Government will propose an amendment at stage two of the bill that would mean any offender would have to intend to stir up hatred.

He has also now said that the SNP are willing to look again at protections of free speech in the legislation.

Mr Yousaf told a parliamentary committee: “I’m very actively considering both the breadth and the depth of freedom-of-expression clauses. We have to be aware of some of the concerns that may be expressed if we were to have a generic freedom-of-expression clause, would that be specific enough to give people the reassurances that they desire?

“We’re looking at all those issues in the round, I would anticipate some further change around the freedom-of-expression clause probably coming at stage two, be it from members or possibly from the Government, but it is an area under active consideration.”



LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here